[Phono-L] Shellac records and damage from steel needles

Rich rich-mail at octoxol.com
Thu Mar 6 07:44:49 PST 2008


It turns out the the DD does experience wear or damage, pick the one you 
like.  And when does wear become damage?

A properly setup and maintained linear tracking arm with a modern low 
mass high compliance cartridge will cause minimum damage to the grove 
walls.  If you cling tenaciously to the pivoted tone arm with its 
changeable geometry and steel needle that needle will wear the grove as 
it rotates in the grove.  You will be shaving rock dust off of the side 
walls as well as continuously reshaping the needle.  Looks like damage 
to me.

Ron L wrote:
<SNIP>
> I think Greg Boganz mentioned the lack of wear on DDs on the Electrola list
> recently.  It is not entirely because of the tone arm and has to do with
> vertical grooves and the nature of the DD surface.
> 
> Ron L


More information about the Phono-L mailing list