[Phono-L] Reproduction grills for Edison machines

Andrew Baron andy at popyrus.com
Mon Jul 16 11:12:08 PDT 2007


Hi all ~
I just wanted to report on a very positive experience that I had with  
my first order from Brian Krapes.  Brian reproduces grills for Edison  
Amberola 1, and various other machines, and has patterns for a number  
of Diamond Disc phonograph grills.  He also makes diaphragms for  
Amberola and DD machines.

The quality of work on the grill he made for me was exceptional and  
the cost was reasonable.  I was most taken with the perfect edges on  
the mahogany-veneered fretwork, with not a trace of tearing or  
splintering, and nice smooth surfaces where the saw blade engaged the  
wood.  For this particular early A-250 grill reproduction, I  
requested and paid a slight additional charge for a slightly over- 
thick fretwork panel to match the over-thick panel on my newer  
A-250.  An additional advantage of this was that I got to have the  
mahogany veneer on both faces of the panel.  (In my recent research  
of the A-250, I've learned that Edison seemed to have progressively  
increased the thickness of the panel, from 1/4" to 5/16" to 3/8",  
from 1912 to late 1914 --  Brian attests to the fact that the slight  
added thickness is a noticeable plus in the free stability of the  
panel).

The surrounding frame was also reproduced to a high level of quality,  
with the correct details as per my original.  The total cost for this  
grill was $140.00, and given that the original was missing on an  
otherwise solid machine, I felt that it was a very sound investment.

Although Brian has patterns for a number of machines, there were  
originally slight variations from one machine to another, even in the  
same model, so to be certain of capturing ALL the details of my  
original, I mailed him an actual tracing of the fretwork panel that I  
made with a fine pencil point against the edges of an original from  
my other machine, and also included a detailed cross-sectional  
drawing of the frame surround.  It was an interesting process to make  
this accurate tracing of the grill, and brought to my attention the  
fact that the factory band-saw work 93 years ago was not perfectly  
accurate and not perfectly symmetrical.  I never noticed this when  
looking at my original grill, but little variations became apparent  
during the faithful tracing of it.  This is due to the hand-made  
nature of that part of the process.  I can attest that Brian's  
accuracy is equal to or slightly better than the original.  He is  
also a pleasure to work with and is receptive to any communication or  
concern.  The grill arrived in good shape and basically ready for  
stain, and required no additional prep work, unless to -slightly- cut  
the edges of the fretwork pattern to make them marginally less sharp.

For those interested in contacting Brian, he can be reached at:  
briankrapes at msn.com

Life has been extra full lately, but I'm still gradually getting my  
A-250 questionnaire summary ready to post to this forum.

Best to all,
Andy Baron


More information about the Phono-L mailing list