[Phono-L] School Presentations

Peter Fraser pjfraser at alamedanet.net
Fri Nov 10 11:15:51 PST 2006


I've given a presentation on Edison, as a person and inventor, to the  
5th grade classes at my kids' elementary school for the past 8  
years.  i bring in a Standard and a Gem or a Q, and a Vic R and an  
orthophonic portable, and samples of various media and misc other  
stuff (including a vinyl LP and a tape cassette, which are becoming  
just as alien as a cylinder record to today's 10 year olds).  i also  
bring a candle and a replica edison bulb, and a recorder and a few  
shaved brown wax cylinders, and a string/tin can telephone.

and then i walk them through a comparison of how they entertain  
themselves today vs before and after Edison's phonograph, and a  
comparison of how we light our rooms.  then we go to demos of home  
recordings (i have an awful rendition of O\ld Black Joe, plus a  
commercial version, which makes for a fun comparison, and no, i don't  
hand out the lyrics to that one). i play some late 20s hot jazz and  
explain how it was music parents didn't like their kids to listen  
to.  the 5th grade kids love hearing that they now have more formal  
education than Edison had.  but their favorite is lining up to record  
their names and a brief phrase onto wax, and then hearing it back.  i  
also usually get one or two of the musically talented ones to record  
a musical performance.  when i can get it together, i burn them CDs  
of their recordings as well, afterwards.

we always talk about who their heros are, and how the heros of  
yesterday are different than many of those of today...and how that  
contributed to the naming of their school when it was founded in the  
early 30s:  Edison Elementary.  this leads to another sort of  
comparison, of what we value in our society now vs what people  
admired then, still rather basic but often remarkably insightful for  
10 year olds.  of course, i live in the sometimes-disdained and  
horrid/ugly/crowded/yaddayadda San Francisco area, where we have  
those awful San Francisco values ("coming soon to a Congress near  
you!"), so your mileage may vary on this particular point.

it's always a gratifying experience, and we have a lot of fun.  i'll  
probably keep doing it even after my kid is out of there.




-- Peter
pjfraser at alamedanet.net






More information about the Phono-L mailing list