[Phono-L] Frozen moments (please read)

Andrew Baron andy at popyrus.com
Sun Dec 31 09:25:42 PST 2006


One of the staples of my school presentations is an Uncle Josh  
recording, usually "Uncle Josh on a Streetcar", along with a typed  
and printed transcription to hand out.  This is chosen in part to  
demonstrate the wide ranging entertainments available on early  
records (this selection has some bits that are just as relevant and  
funny today as they were nearly a century ago), and in part to be  
able to say afterwards that the fellow who just gave them a few  
minutes of delightfully fresh personality was born in 1856.

Other artist they can hear (or even "Let Us Not Forget") feature  
voices of people that were born earlier, but these generally sound  
more or less as the students expect and the fact they were of (to  
them ancient) other times doesn't seem to make much of an  
impression.  They DON'T expect to actually be made to feel an  
emotional response (usually laughter or at least lots of self- 
conscious smiles) to a man born 150 years ago.  When you succeed in  
accomplishing an emotional response to the records and machines, the  
vastness of time and the perception that it doesn't really have  
anything to do with them or their lives evaporates instantly and  
establishes an instant rapport between the student and the material  
being presented.

Andy Baron


On Dec 30, 2006, at 11:52 PM, KEEPERH2O at aol.com wrote:
> In a message dated 12/28/2006 8:18:41 PM Pacific Standard Time,
> john9ten at pacbell.net writes:
> (That sense of presence from all these dead people
> reaching out over a century was simply astonishing...)



More information about the Phono-L mailing list